Does acupuncture help knee pain?
Somewhat, for knee osteoarthritis. A Cochrane review of 16 trials and 3,498 people found acupuncture clearly better than a waiting list, by 14.5 points on a 100-point pain scale, but only 0.9 points on a 20-point scale better than sham needling, below the reviewers' threshold for a meaningful difference. A hot, swollen knee with fever, or one that cannot take weight after an injury, goes to a physician first.
How could needles in and around the knee change pain?
How acupuncture works is not fully understood. The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health describes effects on the nervous system, direct effects on the tissue where the needles are inserted, and nonspecific effects such as expectation. In a 2010 study in mice, needling released adenosine, a compound the body uses to dampen pain signals, and the relief depended on the adenosine A1 receptor. Chinese medicine describes the joint in its own terms: the World Health Organization's standard terminology defines knee impediment as fixed knee pain with swelling, stiffness, and limited movement.
What did the knee osteoarthritis trials and guidelines find?
The 2010 Cochrane review by Manheimer and colleagues pooled 16 randomized trials of osteoarthritis in peripheral joints. Against sham acupuncture, pain at about eight weeks was 0.9 points better on a 20-point scale, below the 1.3 points the reviewers had set as clinically relevant, and by six months the gap was 0.4 points. Against a waiting list it was 14.5 points on a 100-point scale. The reviewers concluded that the benefit over sham is small and probably due at least partly to placebo effects from incomplete blinding.
Two trials show the range. Berman and colleagues gave 570 people with knee osteoarthritis 23 sessions of acupuncture over 26 weeks, sham acupuncture, or an education program; against sham, function was better at 8 and 26 weeks and pain only at 26. Hinman and colleagues randomized 282 people aged 50 or older with chronic knee pain to needle acupuncture, laser acupuncture, sham laser, or no acupuncture for 12 weeks. Needle acupuncture was no better than sham, and its edge over no acupuncture, 1.1 points on a 10-point scale, fell short of the 1.8 points the investigators counted as meaningful and was gone at one year.
Three guidelines read that evidence three ways. The 2019 American College of Rheumatology and Arthritis Foundation guideline conditionally recommends acupuncture for knee, hip, and hand osteoarthritis, noting that the most positive trials are in the knee. The 2021 American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons guideline says acupuncture may improve pain and function in knee osteoarthritis, rates that recommendation limited, and notes there appeared to be no effect in the two studies where blinding was effective. The United Kingdom's NICE guideline of 2022 says not to offer acupuncture or dry needling to manage osteoarthritis.
Which knees respond, and what changes the answer?
The cause comes first. These trials enrolled people with osteoarthritis or long-standing knee pain, so they say nothing about a recent sprain or a torn meniscus. Swelling that follows an injury strongly suggests damage inside the joint and needs an examination before any needling.
Severity and time matter too. The Hinman trial, in people with moderate or severe chronic knee pain, found no benefit over sham. Across chronic pain conditions, a 2018 meta-analysis of 39 trials and 20,827 patients found the effect of a course fell by only about 15 percent at one year, while the Cochrane review found the gap over sham in osteoarthritis had nearly closed at six months.
How is knee pain read and treated in Chinese medicine?
At the practice, knee pain is read by where it sits around the joint and by how the knee responds to climbing, kneeling, damp weather, and rest. Location matters because treatment is directed at the meridians that pass through the painful area. The response to weather and rest places the pain among the patterns Chinese medicine calls impediment, or bi: in the World Health Organization's terminology, cold impediment is fixed joint pain made worse by cold and eased by warmth, dampness impediment is fixed soreness that can come with swelling, and wind impediment is pain that moves from place to place.
Dr. Susan G. Schiff, A.P., DOM, approaches joint pain by finding where the flow of Qi is restricted, and at the first visit we also read the tongue and pulse. Many of the points used for pain sit on the lower legs, so wear something that rolls above the knee. Whether a Chinese herbal formula is added depends on your diagnosis. We do not work from a fixed number of sessions: the plan is built at the first visit and adjusted as you go. What the needles feel like is covered in does acupuncture hurt, and if pain makes the drive hard, she also makes house calls.
When should knee pain see a physician before acupuncture?
The NHS advises urgent help for a knee that is very painful, cannot be moved or take any weight, is badly swollen or has changed shape, or locks, gives way, or clicks painfully, and for a very high temperature with redness or heat around the knee, which can mean infection. An American Family Physician review adds urgent referral for severe pain, swelling, and instability or an inability to bear weight after an injury. Diagnosing the knee belongs to a physician; acupuncture is added once those causes are ruled out.
Acupuncture has risks of its own. The orthopaedic guideline lists soreness and minor bleeding or bruising at the needle sites as the common ones, and advises anyone with a bleeding disorder or a pacemaker, or who could be pregnant, to ask their physician first. In a German survey of 229,230 patients, 8.6 percent reported at least one adverse effect, most often bleeding or a bruise, and two had a collapsed lung.
Common questions
Does Medicare cover acupuncture for knee pain?
No. Medicare's national coverage determination covers acupuncture only for chronic low back pain: up to 12 visits in 90 days, 8 more for patients who are improving, and no more than 20 a year. It states that acupuncture for any other condition is not covered.
How does acupuncture compare with a cortisone injection for knee arthritis?
Guidelines rate the injection higher. The American College of Rheumatology strongly recommends corticosteroid injections for knee osteoarthritis and conditionally recommends acupuncture. The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons rates injections moderate and acupuncture limited, and notes that the injection's effect lasted only up to three months.
Can acupuncture help after a knee replacement?
In the first days, possibly. A 2017 meta-analysis of drug-free treatments after knee replacement found low-certainty evidence that acupuncture lowered pain by about 1.1 points on a 10-point scale at two days, and moderate-certainty evidence that it delayed the first use of opioid pain relief.
Does acupuncture help runner's knee or pain around the kneecap?
The evidence is thin. A 1999 trial of 75 people with patellofemoral pain found better knee scores a year after four weeks of twice-weekly acupuncture than with no treatment. A 2002 trial of 58 people found pain fell equally with deep and with superficial needling.
General information, not medical advice. Acupuncture and Chinese herbal medicine support, and do not replace, care from your physician. Whether treatment fits your situation is decided at a first visit.